Hopeful news for homeowners may not be the best news for the larger US economy. As the 'robo-signer' scandal unfolds, here are the likely consequences.
Questionable paperwork has halted foreclosures across the country, and may give some troubled homeowners the leverage they need to stay in their homes.
Some borrowers have already used lenders' erroneous documentation to get their mortgages legally erased in bankruptcy court. Others hope to use the problems as a levrage to force lenders to reduce their principal or payments.
"You can challenge not only the foreclosure, but (the legitimacy of) the mortgage," said attorney Stephen Elias, the author of "The Foreclosure Survival Guide: Keep Your House or Walk Away with Money in Your Pocket." "You make the allegation that 'we don't think you're going to be able to prove the ownership and the paperwork' . . . that's the thread that, if you pull it, the whole thing will unravel."
The problems stem from the way modern lending is done, and the way lenders have struggled to keep up with a tidal wave of defaulting homeowners. Many mortgages were sold to investors shortly after they were made. Some pieces changed hands several times. Loan servicers, the companies that actually accepted borrowers' payments to forward to the investors, and that are the ones to begin foreclosure proceedings, don't always have the paperwork to prove who owns the loan.
How loan servicers handled foreclosure filings in court is the latest issue. One of the core problems is "robo-signers," or people working on behalf of lenders who signed foreclosure documents without verifying the facts, or even reading what they were signing. It was a way to try to facilitate the process. They've been overwhelmed by the foreclosed properties, and this was their way of trying to get through those problems as fast as they could. Concern about the process has prompted officials to halt foreclosure in many places across the country. Authorities have put the brakes of foreclosures in 23 states as they try to figure out if thousands of homeowners were unfairly booted out of their homes by the banks.
After admitting widespread problems with foreclosure documentation, Bank of America, JPMorgan Chase and Ally Financial's GMAC Mortgage unit suspended tens of thousands of foreclosures in the 23 states where foreclosures go through the courts.
More loan servicers are expected to follow their lead, and the foreclosure freezes could spread to so-called "nonjudicial foreclosure" states where the court system isn't used.
Some of the likely consequences of the scandal:
A big mess for the courts. Experts predict a blizzard of lawsuits over past and current cases, with attempts to get the courts to undo foreclosures and evictions. Foreclosures that were thought to be completed may come back to life "like a hangar-full of dead bodies started to wake up.
A much slower housing recovery. The longer it takes to resolve the foreclosure crisis, the longer the huge inventory of foreclosed homes will weigh on local real-estate markets. Buying a foreclosure may get tougher as title insurers get pickier about which homes they cover. The controversy could scare away potential buyers and lead to even lower home sale prices.
More time for struggling homeowners. Nationwide, the average foreclosure takes nearly 16 months to complete, up from 12 months a year ago, according to LPS Analytics. The foreclosure freeze and attendant regulatory scrutiny are likely to lengthen that wait in many states.